Ultimate RC - Forum Archives


PDA
You are viewing an archive version of a topic

Click here to view the full version : Best XL-5 compatible motor?


Pages : [1] 2

barly
2.04.12, 8:04 pm
Hey guys, I've started something kind of different here. I built my own r/c chassis and A-arms out of some solid hickory at work (dad's a cabinet builder) and I plan to built as much as I can out of steel and wood. I have an XL-5 ESC I'd love to use and I have Stampede tires and body and I'd like to use atleast the tires and ESC. So I was just wondering what the best XL-5 compatible brushed motor would be. I've heard that the Titan 12T 550 isn't a very good quality motor so I'd like some of your ideas of a good brushed motor. I'm not building this for toughness and speed but just the idea "that I built my own r/c" would make it all the more valuble to me. :)

TRD_RockWarrior
2.04.12, 8:25 pm
I have heard that the 15T HPI Firebolt is a pretty solid motor, also the Stock AARMA 15T seems to have plenty of kick, perhaps they are the same motor? I dunno, I have just heard many good stories about them.

indy34096
2.05.12, 5:58 am
Probably the best motor within the limits would be something like a 13t modified motor. Seen a video of one of those and they really are fast!

something like this:
http://www.rcplanet.com/13T_Double_Method_R_Mtr_p/ori25111.htm

Edit: forgot about the 540 limits, sorry, so get something like this instead:
http://www.rcplanet.com/Orion_Method_Modified_15T_Double_p/ori25022.htm

barly
2.05.12, 6:18 am
Okay, thanks for the replys. I'll do more researching on the 3 and see what the final "results" are. I'll let you know what I'm looking at.

Gearz
2.05.12, 7:15 am
I think 15 turns 540 is the motor limit. It can handle a 12 turn 550 because there is more wire per turn on the armature than a 540, and therefore less speed and less current draw.

Fiero_Man_121
2.05.12, 7:28 am
also remember that a heavier car will require more torque, i think a 27t motor would be the ticket.

barly
2.05.12, 9:50 am
So Fier_Man_121, what motor were you thinking about when you said 27T motor would be the ticket. But if the XL-5 ESC has only a 15T limit then.....what then?

What about the Titan 21T motor that's in the Emaxx, I guess that would be to many turns but it sure would have more torque for the heavier r/c.

TurboShadow
2.05.12, 10:27 am
You dont want to use the emaxx motors, they are a 4s motor. Ive heard good things about the firebolt 15t, and it is cheap too. Is there a reason you dont want to run a titan 12t? With a water break in and lipo I think they are pretty impressive.

Fiero_Man_121
2.05.12, 10:28 am
less turns, hotter motor, more turns, slower and torquier (is that a word)

if its just a cobbled car an ole 27t will do. axial makes a non-rebuildable silver can

barly
2.05.12, 10:38 am
Well, I guess the XL-5 ESC, buy the way it sounds, has a 15T limit and I'd need something more, probably.....sigh...... If I would use the 15T firebolt would it be compatible with the XL-5 ESC? Turboshadow, I've heard that the 12T Titans are not the best quality. I went through 3 of 'em in my Stampede in a year but since I'm not going to be doing with this r/c what I did with my Stampede then I guess it might work. What do you mean the "water break in". I'd like to run lipo because they are lighter with more punch.

barly
2.05.12, 12:02 pm
Anybody...?...is the HPI Firebolt 15T compatible with the XL-5 ESC? I'd probably be using this lipo battery.

http://www.hobbypartz.com/77p-sl1600-2s1p-40c-2222.html

TurboShadow
2.05.12, 12:08 pm
Yes but why that battery? 1600 is small and probably wont put out enough amps and will puff. If you on a budget, but this one.

http://www.hobbypartz.com/77p-sl4000-2s1p-20c-2222.html

Less then twice the price and almost 3 times the capacity. I have 4 of them and really like them. My xl5/titan rusty loves them :)

barly
2.05.12, 12:13 pm
Alright, I was going with the higher C rating for the motor's sake but if this works good for you, I'll def. give it a try. Thanks.

TurboShadow
2.05.12, 12:38 pm
1.6AH X 40c = 64 amps the battery can put out

4.0AH X 20c = 80 amps the battery can put out

So, the lower C rating, but higher mah pack will last longer and have more amperage available. :)

barly
2.05.12, 12:41 pm
Thankssss, very much. I'm not a very smart person in that area if r/c LOL

TurboShadow
2.05.12, 12:47 pm
Everyone's got to learn somehow man.

barly
2.05.12, 2:42 pm
:)

I am so excited about continuing on my homemade r/c. I have mostly everything planned how I'm going to do it but I could easily be missing something. These are the only things I'm going to be buying.

Driveshafts - http://www.ebay.com/itm/Traxxas-Rustler-3705-XL-5-Rear-Driveshafts-Axles-Hexes-Drive-Pins-Nuts-/270904820465?_trksid=p5197.m7&_trkparms=algo%3DLVI%26itu%3DUCI%26otn%3D5%26po%3DLVI%26ps%3D63%26clkid%3D6124281260178069655

Transmission - http://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Traxxas-Stampede-Rustler-Slash-Brushless-VXL-XL5-full-Magnum-Transmission-/110813181787?pt=Radio_Control_Parts_Accessories&hash=item19ccfaf75b

HPI Firebolt 15T - http://www.ebay.com/itm/HPI-Racing-FIREBOLT-15T-Upgrade-RC-Electric-Motor-1146-/320825577793?pt=UK_ToysGames_RadioControlled_JN&hash=item4ab2b1d141

Servo - http://www.hobbypartz.com/60gexidised2.html

Battery - http://www.hobbypartz.com/77p-sl4000-2s1p-20c-2222.html

And then some gears and connectors. If you have any better ideas that what I have listed here, let me know. :) I am planning to buy the items from ebay tomorrow or sooner so speak up if you have a better idea.

Gearz
2.05.12, 3:38 pm
If you can afford it, go with a Gens Ace 5000MaH 40C LiPo (direct version) from Hobbypartz. Everyone seems to like those.

barly
2.05.12, 3:41 pm
I'm on a budget and that's the reason I'm building my own r/c. Does everything else look like good choices though?

TurboShadow
2.05.12, 5:44 pm
I really think you would be better of buying a used traxxas 2wd roller of some kind and then modifying it, instead of starting from scratch if this is your first custom build.